« Quote for the Day |
Main
| Fire Rumsfeld Now »
05 Jun 2006 02:34 pm
We Torture
And so the Cheney-Rumsfeld combo strikes again. The McCain Amendment, we find out, as if we didn't already know, was irrelevant. We thought we still lived in a constitutional democracy where the Congress regulates the rules of war, as specified in the Constitution itself. No longer. Bush's signing statement on the McCain Amendment was the first signal. Now we have the second. The new version of the Army Feld Manual will maintain the removal of any reference to the basic Article 3 in the Geneva Conventions with respect to military detainees. There had been an attempt to reinstate it, on the delusion that we still live in a country where the executive enforces the rule of law. But it was foiled by the usual suspects:
The move to restore U.S. adherence to Article 3 was opposed by officials from Vice President Dick Cheney's office and by the Pentagon's intelligence arm, government sources said. David S. Addington, Cheney's chief of staff, and Stephen A. Cambone, Defense undersecretary for intelligence, said it would restrict the United States' ability to question detainees.
The Pentagon tried to satisfy some of the military lawyers' concerns by including some protections of Article 3 in the new policy, most notably a ban on inhumane treatment, but refused to embrace the actual Geneva standard in the directive it planned to issue.
The military lawyers, known as judge advocates general, or JAGs, have concluded that they will have to wait for a new administration before mounting another push to link Pentagon policy to the standards of Geneva.
Can you believe what you're reading? This is not some tight exclusion for a handful of CIA officials to torture detainees. This is a carte blanche for the military as a whole. The argument is the same that we have always had:
But top administration officials contend that after the Sept. 11 attacks, old customs do not apply, especially to a fight against terrorists or insurgents who never play by the rules. "The overall thinking," said the participant familiar with the defense debate, "is that they need the flexibility to apply cruel techniques if military necessity requires it."
The United States is a rogue nation that practices torture and detainee abuse and does not follow the most basic principles of the Geneva Conventions. It is inviolation of human rights agreements and the U.N. Convention against torture. It is legitimizing torture by every disgusting regime on the planet. This is a policy mandated by the president and his closest advisers. This is the signal being sent from the commander-in-chief to his troops: your enemy can be treated beyond the boundaries of what the U.S. has always abided by. When you next read of an atrocity of war-crime or victim of torture by the U.S., just keep in mind who made this possible. Keep your eyes not just on the troops but on the people giving them the orders. My column on Bush's responsibility can be read here.
Share This
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451c45669e200d83467ea8b69e2
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference 'We Torture'
HADITHA HYPERVENTILATION
Excerpt: We name the top five MSM heavy-breathers over at Hot Air. The NY Slimes earned the Number 3 spot (thanks to Sanctuary for the photoshop): Unfortunately, we finished this show before Andrew Sullivan labeled America a "rogue nation" today. Yeah,...
Weblog: Michelle Malkin
Tracked: Jun 5, 2006 2:53:39 PM
Pentagon Strikes Humane Treatment from Field Manual
Excerpt: As the Army is in the midst of trying soldiers for abuses in Abu Ghraib and CENTCOM is conducting training classes reminding soldiers that murdering civilians is a violation of the Code of Conduct, the Pentagon is rewriting its training manuals to omit...
Weblog: Outside The Beltway | OTB
Tracked: Jun 5, 2006 3:05:38 PM
Bye Bye, Geneva
Excerpt: Reading the article, it strikes me again as to how humane and decent our soldiers are. Too bad their Commander-in-Chief isn\'t worthy of them.
Weblog: Mike's Meandering Mind
Tracked: Jun 5, 2006 3:20:02 PM
Andrew Sullivan- US is a rogue nation.
Excerpt: Andrew Sullivan- US is a rogue nation.
Weblog: discarded lies - hyperlinkopotamus
Tracked: Jun 5, 2006 3:25:13 PM
Conservative Stalwart Andrew Sullivan is MORE MORAL THAN THOU
Excerpt: At the risk of prompting unstable people to issue anonymous threats against his beagle, I reprint this latest from The Daily Dish:The United States is a rogue nation that practices torture and detainee abuse and does not follow the most basic princi...
Weblog: protein wisdom
Tracked: Jun 5, 2006 3:36:14 PM
Human Rights Watch details CIA renditions, abuse and executions
Excerpt: Andrew Sullivan takes time to remind us why the Bush Administration is so dastardly. H/T Michelle Malkin. But here is some background that Andrew left out. Thats right: Human Rights Watch U.S. government moved against a group of alleged militants
Weblog: Ray Robison
Tracked: Jun 5, 2006 3:37:27 PM
Sullivan: U.S. is a "Rogue Nation"
Excerpt: The United States is on par with Stallinist North Korea and millitant Iran. At least that's what Andrew Sullivan declares...
Weblog: The American Mind
Tracked: Jun 5, 2006 4:10:29 PM
Army Manuel Omits Geneva Conventions Ban On Humiliating Prisoners
Excerpt: Heres the controversy of the day.
Here is a reaction. Can you guess who said it?
The United States is a rogue nation that practices torture and detainee abuse and does not follow the most basic principles of the Geneva Conventions. It is i...
Weblog: Stop The ACLU
Tracked: Jun 5, 2006 4:29:47 PM
Respect the JAG Officers
Excerpt: Maybe its because Im a lawyer, or maybe its because I know a few JAG officers, or maybe its just because they do the right thing, but I have a tremendous amount of respect for JAGs.
Sullivan links to this article in the LA...
Weblog: Cagey Mind
Tracked: Jun 5, 2006 4:31:04 PM
Pentagon withdraws from Geneva Convention
Excerpt: Look, if we're going to effectively abandon the Geneva Convention on treatment of POWs, then let's actually withdraw. Let's not argue semantics, exigencies and tu quoque. If our leadership is confident
Weblog: QandO
Tracked: Jun 5, 2006 5:43:46 PM
Torture is complicated
Excerpt: "How do we define "torture?" And is it ever okay to do it, and if so, what are our criteria? At the Hadar retreat I had an intelligent reality-based conversation about the conduct of the Iraq reconstruction, and the subject...
Weblog: Kesher Talk
Tracked: Jun 5, 2006 7:30:01 PM
Torture is complicated
Excerpt: "How do we define "torture?" And is it ever okay to do it, and if so, what are our criteria? At the Hadar retreat I had an intelligent reality-based conversation about the conduct of the Iraq reconstruction, and the subject...
Weblog: Kesher Talk
Tracked: Jun 5, 2006 7:33:04 PM
Sullivan Denounces U.S. for Legitimizing Torture
Excerpt: Andrew Sullivan makes a strong case that because of U.S. policies regarding treatment of captives, we legitimize any torture of an American soldier abroad. However, Sullivans strong case is quickly pulled apart into its separate pieces and the...
Weblog: Strategic Outlook Institute - Weblog
Tracked: Jun 5, 2006 7:43:57 PM
Torture is complicated
Excerpt: "How do we define "torture?" And is it ever okay to do it, and if so, what are our criteria for deciding that? Torture is one of those topics - like slavery or porn -...
Weblog: Winds of Change.NET
Tracked: Jun 5, 2006 7:54:07 PM
Torture is complicated
Excerpt: "How do we define "torture?" And is it ever okay to do it, and if so, what are our criteria for deciding that? At the Hadar retreat I had an intelligent reality-based conversation about the conduct of the Iraq reconstruction,...
Weblog: Kesher Talk
Tracked: Jun 5, 2006 8:29:29 PM
Army Manual To Omit Geneva Detainee Rule
Excerpt: LA Times
WASHINGTON - The Pentagon has decided to omit from new detainee policies a key tenet of the Geneva Convention that explicitly bans humiliating and degrading treatment, according to knowledgeable military officials, a step that ...
Weblog: An Army Lawyer
Tracked: Jun 5, 2006 9:32:13 PM
Army Manual To Omit Geneva Common Article 3
Excerpt: LA TimesWASHINGTON - The Pentagon has decided to omit from new detainee policies a key tenet of the Geneva Convention that explicitly bans "humiliating and degrading treatment," according to knowledgeable military officials, a step that would mark a fu...
Weblog: MilBlogs
Tracked: Jun 5, 2006 9:35:18 PM
DoD, Torture and the Field Manual
Excerpt: Andrew Sullivan doesn't get it, but that's predictable. The astute Jeff Goldstein misses it as well. James Joyner has also missed the point.
The DoD isn't trying to circumvent anything, or being sneaky or define anything. They are demonstrating, u...
Weblog: Signaleer
Tracked: Jun 5, 2006 9:47:09 PM
The U.S. Tortures
Excerpt: Read Andrew Sullivan's entry: The United States is a rogue nation that practices torture and detainee abuse and does not follow the most basic principles of the Geneva Conventions. It is in violation of human rights agreements and the U.N....
Weblog: Democracy
Tracked: Jun 5, 2006 11:06:29 PM
Conservatives for gay sexual abuse
Excerpt: It is mind-boggling to think that the same administration that is pushing for a Constitutional amendment banning gay marriage would be dropping regulations designed to prevent the "humiliating and degrading treatment" of prisoners - which, in the case ...
Weblog: outragedmoderates.org
Tracked: Jun 6, 2006 12:05:32 AM
Humiliation and torture
Excerpt: Quite some time ago, I grew tired of arguing that Christina Aguillera music, ridicule, and "invasion of space by a female" aren't torture. So, now that Andrew Sullivan has declared the U.S. a "rogue nation" for failing to protect detainees from ...
Weblog: rgcombs.blog-city.com
Tracked: Jun 6, 2006 4:49:03 AM
WAR: Rewriting The Army Field Manual
Excerpt: Jon Henke points us to this LA Times article citing anonymous sources discussing revisions supposedly* being made to the Army Field Manual regarding interrogation of detainees in response to the McCain Amendment, which was designed to raise the standar...
Weblog: Baseball Crank
Tracked: Jun 6, 2006 12:56:04 PM
WAR: Rewriting The Army Field Manual
Excerpt: Jon Henke points us to this LA Times article citing anonymous sources discussing revisions supposedly* being made to the Army Field Manual regarding interrogation of detainees in response to the McCain Amendment, which was designed to raise the standar...
Weblog: Baseball Crank
Tracked: Jun 6, 2006 1:03:50 PM
Miscellaneous Commentary For June 06, 2006
Excerpt: -- The really ironic thing about this transcript that feature Matt Lauer attacking Ann Coulter for ripping on the Jersey...
Weblog: Right Wing News
Tracked: Jun 7, 2006 1:10:57 AM
Miscellaneous Commentary For June 07, 2006
Excerpt: -- The really ironic thing about this transcript that features Matt Lauer attacking Ann Coulter for ripping on the Jersey...
Weblog: Right Wing News
Tracked: Jun 7, 2006 1:00:08 PM
On Iraq
Excerpt: I wrote this post and saved it as a draft about an hour after I read this article.
Army Manual to Skip Geneva Detainee Rule
The Pentagons move to omit a ban on prisoner humiliation from the basic guide to soldier conduct faces strong State Dept....
Weblog: BuffaloGeek
Tracked: Jun 15, 2006 3:23:07 AM
Our Call to Bush: Come Clean
Excerpt: The SC has declared Bush's Guantanamo tribunals illegal. Besides, they violate the Geneva Conventions as Amnesty International noted almost 4 years ago:The US Government has paid lip service to the Geneva Conventions - the principal and almost universa...
Weblog: Lam(b)
Tracked: Jun 30, 2006 3:44:45 AM
Site Meter 
