« Impeach Cheney | Main | Europe's Beleaguered Drug Companies »
Cures Or Treatments?
28 Jun 2007 04:22 pm
A reader raises an interesting question on healthcare:
I tend to agree that we should let the market drive innovation through rewarding solid research and groundbreaking results with profits that can feed further developments. What worries me is that when money is your motivator, what sort of research has a greater chance of being funded: a treatment, or a cure?
There isn't much to be gained, from a financial perspective, from a cure. Treatment, however, is a goldmine. Improving the quality of life for the sick is certainly a noble goal, but I fear that when money is the sole motivator then we will have executives deciding between pursuing a cure and pursuing treatment for symptoms - and choosing the latter every time.
Not that I'm suggesting socialized medicine would help - at least, not on its own. If the profit for drug research is slashed by government caps on prices, then it becomes a question of who picks up the financial slack and enables continued innovation?
If the government picks up this slack, perhaps they could have some say in the matter, drive decisions toward cures instead of treatments when possible. The government could save some cost when a cure replaces a treatment, so the motivation would be there. But this is all pure speculation on my part, so I'm turning to you and your readers to find out if current socialized systems see any such effects?
No idea. But I'm sure other readers can help. With HIV, the problem is the extreme elusiveness of a mutating retrovirus that makes a vaccine-cure close to impossible. The good side of treatments, moreover, is that they do reduce your viral load in most cases to a negligible level. That makes you much less infectious, which helps restrain the epidemic. And so a treatment becomes a prophylaxis.
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/t/trackback/2224950/19667064
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference 'Cures Or Treatments?'
I have more faith in intellect than steel.
Excerpt: Let's just keep pretending that not can we predict the future, but we also know that future definitively will not contain better treatments for HIV. Or even possibly a cure:In a breakthrough that could potentially lead to a cure for...
Weblog: RollingDoughnut.com
Tracked: Jul 1, 2007 6:15:30 PM
