Saturday, December 20, 200820 Dec 2008 08:42 pm The Spirit Of Conor Cruise O'BrienI have to say that Yuval Levin's appreciation of "The Great Melody" expresses my feelings about that book entirely. It's a very strange book - my mind associates it with Edmund Morris's "Dutch" - but its strangeness captures the elusive, contradictory, Irish (and Whiggish) Toryism of Burke. The Telegraph's obit, as usual, is the best:
A role model in many ways for all of us. I only met him once. He came to Harvard to speak about the essence of Irish culture and was completely shitfaced afterwards. Coming from a long line of ornery Micks, I appreciated that. 20 Dec 2008 08:29 pm The Bailout ExplainedNot sure where this originated. But it's on the money: 20 Dec 2008 07:20 pm "Addict" AddictsVaughan sighs:
Continue reading ""Addict" Addicts" » 20 Dec 2008 06:22 pm Face Of The DayA riot police officer guards the Athens' christmas tree at Syntagma squre during a protest on December 20, 2008. After two weeks of clashes, as the government faced growing pressure over its handling of the crisis sparked by the December 6 police killing of a teenager. By Aris Messinis/AFP/Getty Images. 20 Dec 2008 05:17 pm The Vulgarity Of The WebIs it destroying literate discourse? Is it dumbing us all down? CJR has a fascinating interview with Clay Shirky:
Continue reading "The Vulgarity Of The Web" » 20 Dec 2008 05:02 pm The Social Is SurgicalSaletan writes about a face-transplant:
Poulos grinds his teeth. 20 Dec 2008 04:31 pm "Yes, But After"A friend sends along this little gem of an interview between John Lofton and Allen Ginsberg. Money quote:
20 Dec 2008 03:11 pm Freedom Or Power?In many ways, I think those two polarities often expose the deeper fault-lines in our politics than right or left (because the choice between freedom and power exists within both right and left as well). And this Rick Warren flap at its core, I think, is about the difference between those who see a civil rights movement as a means to wield power and those who see it as a means to spread freedom. My long conflict with some parts of the gay left is precisely about this distinction, and Virtually Normal was an attempt to construct a theory for gay civil rights which rests on as much freedom and as little power as possible. I want to live in a free society alongside people who genuinely believe I am a sinner destined for hell - and I want to get along with them. I am concerned (but not obsessed) with changing their minds, but totally repelled by the idea of coercing or pressuring them to do so. I am simply interested in having the government treat me as it would treat them. Once we establish that, we can all believe and say and argue for precisely what we want. May a thousand theologies bloom. So I oppose hate crime laws because they walk too close to the line of trying to police people's thoughts. I deliberately framed my own case for gay rights away from forcing or even pressuring any other citizen to accept me - because that impedes their freedom and, in my view, the gay movement should always, always be about expanding freedom for everyone, even bigots. That's why I focused on the government treating gays and straights alike. And so the notion of the president stigmatizing someone because of his religious views, and the gay movement pressuring to ban such a person from a civic ceremony, strikes me as coming from precisely the wrong place. A president is president of all the people. Unlike Bush, Obama means it. And unlike Bush, he has already proven it. Can you imagine if Bush had asked an openly gay minister to give his Invocation? That would have been the unifying move - and opened up a new space for dialogue. But Bush closed it down. I did not endorse Obama to perpetuate that kind of politics. Using government to advance the worldview of one group of people and to stigmatize another is exactly what went wrong these past eight years. Besides, if we stick rigorously to the cause of freedom and toleration, we win the argument. We already have. The impulse to engage now in tit-for-tat, or to use power not to advance our freedom but to impede others', is a dead, dispiriting end. It is particularly stupid when it is the only way we will lose - by turning this into a battle in which gay people are described as intolerant and evangelicals are described as open to debate. Much more important, with Obama's election, power has shifted. Gay people helped win this election. We will be part of this administration in ways that we would never be under a McCain or a Bush. Yes, we should demand change and hold Obama accountable in every respect. But this is not 1992. It's 2008. Our biggest loss in the biggest state on a question The key point about marriage rights for gays, after all, is that they do not affect or change marriage rights for straights. No one's rights are removed. In fact, as I have discovered, straight family members often find their own marriages affirmed by their gay siblings' commitment. It is win-win - an expansion of freedom and social stability. And the key to succeeding as a civil rights movement, as King taught us, is never to give in to the intolerance of the other side by engaging in it yourself; never engage in violence or intimidation; never try to force anyone to do anything they do not want to do; always respect others' consciences. And this is why I think gay people of faith have a central role to play now. In the battle between a frightened fundamentalism and a wounded gay community, we are called to be healers and bridge builders. This is our Christian obligation, the part we have to play. The dynamic between the short-term pleasure of power and the long-term argument for freedom affects all civil rights movements. The central element in the success of black civil rights was the role of Christianity in tempering and guiding and restraining the temptations of power in favor of the deferred promises of freedom and charity. Gay Christians are needed now as much as ever to help in that task, however hard it can be to swallow the spiritual hurt and to rise above it in charity. I know how hard that is, and I haven't met the standard always myself. I'm not preaching; I'm just saying what I've learned - in prayer and in action. Every day, with everyone you meet, do what you can. 20 Dec 2008 02:54 pm "Judicial Tyranny"One useful data point from the NYT today. In 1968, a year after the Supreme Court struck down anti-miscegenation laws:
And around 53 percent of non-gays voted against marriage equality in Prop 8 forty years later. So sme things don;t change. In fact, the popular hostility to miscegnation in America was far deeper and wider in the 1960s than hostility to gay marriage today. And yet that broad popular majority did not intimidate the courts then, did it? 20 Dec 2008 02:47 pm Death By WeatherVia Tyler Cowen, a chart showing where one is most likely to die from weather. The conclusion:
Drum gloats about Southern California being among the safest places in the country. He then concludes: "On the other hand, we're still waiting for the Big One out here. This map could change color at any time." And the chart does not account for that slow, psychological death from the weather, otherwise known as England and Oregon. 20 Dec 2008 02:36 pm Reality CheckA reader writes:
Three words for the liberal Reagan: trust but verify. 20 Dec 2008 01:56 pm Christmas Hathos NomineeBest not to watch this if you're dropping acid: 20 Dec 2008 01:33 pm Sued On FacebookAn Australian court rules that posting on someone's Facebook page can be used to serve legal papers. Cory Doctorow is unimpressed:
20 Dec 2008 12:32 pm TrustGreenwald responds:
20 Dec 2008 11:11 am The Best Journalism Of 2008A weekend reader from Conor. 20 Dec 2008 10:27 am The View From Your WindowCairo, Egypt, 2 pm. 20 Dec 2008 09:28 am 5 Second SpotsCopyranter thinks they may be the future of advertising. 20 Dec 2008 08:48 am White-Collar WelfareHilzoy disagrees with the new "health worker protections" implemented by Bush:
Friday, December 19, 200819 Dec 2008 09:13 pm Christmas Hathos NomineeNo one does Christmas like Mormons. Over to Donny and Marie (if you make it through these seven minutes, you have a stronger stomach than I do): 19 Dec 2008 07:27 pm Taking Yes For An AnswerMy final take on the Rick Warren affair. 19 Dec 2008 06:47 pm Caroline as Princess Leia?Carl Cannon outdoes himself in Kennedy goo, lamenting the premature death of John F Kennedy Jr:
19 Dec 2008 06:16 pm Face Of The DayA woman in a knit cap waits to walk across a street during a snowstorm December 19, 2008 on the Upper East Side of Manhattan in New York City. New York's first snowstorm of the season was expected to bring up to six inches of accumulation. By Chris Hondros/Getty. 19 Dec 2008 06:11 pm More Sense Than BushMcCain speaks out against the bailout:
19 Dec 2008 05:50 pm Ta-Da!The NYT Op-Ed page stumbles across the blogosphere. 19 Dec 2008 05:23 pm Uh-OhHugh Hewitt approves of Bush bailing out the big three:
I'm sorry to say I don't find any of the assurances that the car companies will ever start making money persuasive. And the Bush gambit is of a piece with the rest of his legacy: a carefully wrapped ticking bomb that will explode over us slowly over the next decade. From Iraq to Afghanistan to Gitmo to the doubling of the national debt: it is a legacy of reckless, stupid governance by an irresponsible president trying to cover his ass on the way out. (Hat tip: Cole) 19 Dec 2008 04:52 pm Changing MindsA reader writes:
Continue reading "Changing Minds" » 19 Dec 2008 04:35 pm What's Taking So Long In Minnesota?They are having ten minute conversations about the existence of Lizard People. As of last night Coleman was citing a 2 vote lead. Now Frankin appears to be up for the first time. Nate Silver's guess:
19 Dec 2008 04:20 pm Mental Health BreakHappy Christmas (yes, my roots are showing): 19 Dec 2008 04:08 pm Local News
19 Dec 2008 03:45 pm The Appeals Court Of HistoryBeam analyzes Bush's legacy tour:
One recalls Lionel Trilling's comment on Tacitus:
19 Dec 2008 03:26 pm Not Gonna HappenJuan Cole lists ten reasons why the US shouldn't put up permanent bases in Iraq. 19 Dec 2008 03:10 pm Freedom or Marriage?, CtdJoe Carter responds:
Here's part of a post by Dale Carpenter about religious freedom and marriage equality from earlier this year: Continue reading "Freedom or Marriage?, Ctd" » 19 Dec 2008 02:47 pm Christmas Hathos NomineeLadies and gentlemen, I present Mr Rick Astley (not a rick-roll, promise): 19 Dec 2008 02:44 pm Something Good About WarrenFrom huffpost, of all places:
(Hat tip: Frum) 19 Dec 2008 02:25 pm The View From Your WindowBend, Oregon, 10 pm. 19 Dec 2008 02:22 pm That Alleged Baathist Coup, Ctd.Judah Grunstein sizes up the news from Baghdad:
19 Dec 2008 01:44 pm Yglesias Award Nominee"I have given up trying to convince most of my conservative friends of the necessity of speaking out against what has transpired these last several years with regards to the approval of torture at the highest levels of our government. But I will continue to write about it because it is something about which I feel very strongly. I will not, as many liberals do, berate those of you who disagree with me. This is a matter of conscience. Each of us must examine our own beliefs, our own mind, and come to our own conclusions in this matter. Continue reading "Yglesias Award Nominee" » 19 Dec 2008 12:40 pm Taking Yes For An AnswerDish readers will know my own conflicted feelings about the selection of Rick Warren for the Inaugural Invocation. But feelings must at some point cede to reason. And I sense an understandable but, the more I think about it, misjudged response on the part of my fellow gays and lesbians. In our hurt, we may be pushing away from a real opportunity to engage and win hearts and minds. Here's Glenn Greenwald:
I disagree. I think Obama is different. I think the earnestness and sincerity of his campaign, and its generational force, have given us a chance for something new, and I fear that in responding too viscerally to the Warren choice, we may be throwing something very valuable away far too prematurely. There is no question that gays and lesbians have made enormous strides in explaining who we are in the last couple of decades. There is equally no question that Obama has substantively committed his administration to more gay inclusion and gay equality than any president in history. We absolutely do need to be vigilant on this. But we should also understand Obama's attempt to bridge some gaps in America that the Clintons, with their boomer baggage and Dick Morris cynicism, couldn't and didn't. This is what matters. Do gays and lesbians want to be a part of this - or sit fuming on the sidelines at symbolic slights? I know the arguments against this, and if Obama delivers nothing on gay equality, the critics will have every reason to complain loudly, as they should. But I'm not going there yet. And the truth is: if we cannot engage a Rick Warren on the question of our equality, we may secure a narrow and bitter victory in some states (just as the Christianists won a narrow and bitter victory in California in November). But we will not win the bigger argument and our victories will lack the moral legitimacy they deserve. The greatest distortion of our politics in this respect is the notion that gays are in some way opposed to faith and in some way that our cause is a function solely of the left. Neither is true. Continue reading "Taking Yes For An Answer" » 19 Dec 2008 12:33 pm Caroline Palin, Ctd.Just another flash of recognition:
Paging Katie Couric. 19 Dec 2008 12:24 pm Another Bank Bailout?Manzi sums up where we are at:
Continue reading "Another Bank Bailout?" » 19 Dec 2008 12:11 pm Is The Detroit Bailout Illegal?Michelle Malkin wants to know. 19 Dec 2008 12:08 pm Warren On AtheistsHeather Mac Donald is outraged by the Warren pick. Here's why:
And, of course, not all atheists are on the left. 19 Dec 2008 11:38 am Why?Did Wikileaks go too far? It seems so. 19 Dec 2008 11:14 am Not Going To Hell YetJoe Klein doesn't mind the Warren choice:
One thing I'd say in defense of Obama. There were a few times in the campaign when my first reaction was that he had screwed up. In almost every case, he subsequently proved me wrong. And I think we need to take him seriously about a change in tone on these subjects. He's asking a lot from us. That doesn't mean we should not try to reciprocate. More later. 19 Dec 2008 11:00 am A Ministry Tool-BoxErica Barnett has rounded up some of Warren's greatest hits. I forgot that he backed the Federal Marriage Amendment, the most extreme anti-marriage policy option on the table. 19 Dec 2008 10:38 am Less Qualified Than PalinI was struck by this story in the NYT this morning:
Remind you of anyone? Continue reading "Less Qualified Than Palin" » 19 Dec 2008 10:33 am America AloneWell, Mark Steyn will be happy. 19 Dec 2008 10:29 am Occasional PoetsPacker doesn't want poetry at the Inauguration:
I say: give her a chance. I guess at this point I'm grateful he didn't ask James Dobson. 19 Dec 2008 10:21 am The T-WordWhy is the press so scared of the English language? 19 Dec 2008 09:40 am Christmas Hathos NomineeThe competition heats up. David Hasselhoff sings Stille Nacht: |













